A week ago you accused Ant of not participating in Seder and yet in his subsequent point he pointed out that he did indeed take part, in Washington Square, NY.

You're arguments are purely emotional and rather desperate.

There are six million Arabs who care about a Palestinian state

Ah, but do they care about it more, or less than killing Jews?

And what do you mean by “another” Palestinian state?

I assume he was referring to Jordan.

Ant’s ideology is not about the destruction of Israel

Oh really?

As a Jew who doesn't believe in the concept of a Jewish state — Antony Loewenstein

He may have watered down his extremist views in order to make them more palatable and attract more signatures to his petition, but that doesn't change them. It is intellectual dishonesty and the reason several signatories retracted their support when they realised his true agenda.

And what do you mean by “another” Palestinian state?

And no, Ant’s ideology is not about the destruction of Israel. In fact, the charter of Independent Jewish Voices in Australia stipulates the recognition of Israel.

Viva, you are really showing very poor form. Is your position so dour that you have to resort to such baseless ad hominems and straw men?

Actually this whole blog exists to destroy Israel.

With the exception of extremist groups, the only people who ever raise the issue of Israel's right to exist seem to be Zionist. Even Israel's harshest critics do not dispute Israel's right to exist, largely because it is a straw man argument and a nonsequitur, yet wherever Israel is criticized, it is given undue prominence.

Any reasonable and responsible individual would advocate Israel's right to exist. What is clear however, is that there are elements among Zionists, who associate Israel's existence with the prevention of the creation of Palestinian state.

Why one are you?

Your paranoia is steadily increasing by the day. Firstly, whiel this blog ais to promote discussion and awareness, thre is no desire, much less the means to destroy Israel. O the contrary, Ant has repeated that Israel’s existence is threatened by it’s own policies.

Unless of course you are among those that are convinced Israel’s existence is inextricably linked to the enthic cleansing of Arabs from Israel proper, the occupied territories and the preventing the creation of a Palestinian State?

what do you mean by myth?….jerusalem has been important to the jews since ever. are you saying it isn’t holy anymore?

im an israeli jew who constantly criticizes israel. but im a zionist, meaning, i believe in my country’s right to exist. you dont’?

Danielle